I didn’t know about this movie until the last quarter of the previous year after my younger brother became a fan of the Silent Hill games and we both found out this movie was a heavy influence on them. The fact it was directed by Adrian Lyne after he did Fatal Attraction made me more interested in watching it.
The tagline of the film really lets you know what you are in for: The most frightening thing about Jacob Singer’s nightmare is that he isn’t dreaming. The film truly does have a nightmarish tone to it, especially since it’s a psychological horror. While there is some blood and a small amount of gore, the real horror comes from the unsettling visions Jacob experiences, his despair over the death of his son, and how he can no longer trust his own mind. The intensity of this film was stronger than what I felt watching most horror movies people are familiar with like The Exorcist and one of the few movies that rivals it in my opinion is Andrzej Żuławski’s Possession (1981). As indicated by the title, there is some religious symbolism in the film but it does not ever become preachy or pretentious.
The film opens in 1971 with Jacob Singer with his platoon in Vietnam which comes under attack. His buddies start suffering from strange convulsions and he runs into the jungles only to be stabbed by an out of shot attacker. He then next finds himself in a New York subway in 1975 as if he woke from a dream and soon starts seeing bizarre things almost everywhere he goes. Some of these visions are of unearthly figures whose faces twist and contort violently like some of the monsters in Silent Hill. As the visions get worse and his surviving friends express similar stories, he attempts to uncover what’s really happening to him. It leads into a journey that is both intense as well as heart string tugging.
According to Adrian Lyne, test audiences found the movie overwhelming so he removed 20 minutes of footage before it was released in cinemas. A TV version of the movie once aired with a number of these scenes restored and they can also be seen on the DVD releases as well as in the two making of documentaries. The movie is already disturbing but after seeing what’s been preserved of the removed footage as well as what the script describes of what hasn’t yet been shown yet, the film would’ve been even more horrifying.
I haven’t watched the 2019 remake and all the reviews I’ve read as well as watched say it is an insult to the original since it removes certain aspects of the original such as a father’s despair and the deeper questions asked by replacing them with cliched jump scares and action sequences.
Does anyone else have thoughts on this movie?
The tagline of the film really lets you know what you are in for: The most frightening thing about Jacob Singer’s nightmare is that he isn’t dreaming. The film truly does have a nightmarish tone to it, especially since it’s a psychological horror. While there is some blood and a small amount of gore, the real horror comes from the unsettling visions Jacob experiences, his despair over the death of his son, and how he can no longer trust his own mind. The intensity of this film was stronger than what I felt watching most horror movies people are familiar with like The Exorcist and one of the few movies that rivals it in my opinion is Andrzej Żuławski’s Possession (1981). As indicated by the title, there is some religious symbolism in the film but it does not ever become preachy or pretentious.
The film opens in 1971 with Jacob Singer with his platoon in Vietnam which comes under attack. His buddies start suffering from strange convulsions and he runs into the jungles only to be stabbed by an out of shot attacker. He then next finds himself in a New York subway in 1975 as if he woke from a dream and soon starts seeing bizarre things almost everywhere he goes. Some of these visions are of unearthly figures whose faces twist and contort violently like some of the monsters in Silent Hill. As the visions get worse and his surviving friends express similar stories, he attempts to uncover what’s really happening to him. It leads into a journey that is both intense as well as heart string tugging.
According to Adrian Lyne, test audiences found the movie overwhelming so he removed 20 minutes of footage before it was released in cinemas. A TV version of the movie once aired with a number of these scenes restored and they can also be seen on the DVD releases as well as in the two making of documentaries. The movie is already disturbing but after seeing what’s been preserved of the removed footage as well as what the script describes of what hasn’t yet been shown yet, the film would’ve been even more horrifying.
I haven’t watched the 2019 remake and all the reviews I’ve read as well as watched say it is an insult to the original since it removes certain aspects of the original such as a father’s despair and the deeper questions asked by replacing them with cliched jump scares and action sequences.
Does anyone else have thoughts on this movie?
Last edited: