• Welcome to Autism Forums, a friendly forum to discuss Aspergers Syndrome, Autism, High Functioning Autism and related conditions.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Private Member only forums for more serious discussions that you may wish to not have guests or search engines access to.
    • Your very own blog. Write about anything you like on your own individual blog.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon! Please also check us out @ https://www.twitter.com/aspiescentral

There's a Simple Optical Illusion That Could Help Diagnose Autism

AGXStarseed

Well-Known Member
(Not written by me)

Accurately arriving at a diagnosis for autism spectrum disorder can be challenging, especially in cases that appear to be borderline.

By noting the way a person's pupils dilate as they watch a column of shifting dots, specialists might soon have one more clue to help them determine which way someone's brain is wired.


The discovery comes from a team of researchers based at the University of Pisa in Italy, who found a simple optical illusion could be used to objectively detect how some individuals tend to zoom in on details and miss the bigger picture.

Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) covers a range of traits, all of which can range from mild to severe in effect.

These typically include difficulties in fine motor control and processing sensory information, leading to behaviours such as avoidance of overstimulation or repetitive movements.

Communicating and responding to social cues can also be a challenge, giving rise to anything from difficulties with pragmatic language skills to being completely non-verbal.

With so many boxes to tick and such variety in how it presents – not to mention the fact it typically only becomes recognisable a few years after birth – ASD can easily be missed.

Having another tool that draws a clear distinction could help ASD specialists make the call on a diagnosis.

This method uses two layers of contrasting dots that move in opposite directions inside a narrow column.

Take a look at it below, and ask yourself – is the column rotating, or are they just two sheets of dots sliding across each other?

rotating_column.gif


Don't worry if you see it switch back and forth. Our brain often wavers in its attempts to settle on the meaning of a picture, just as it does with 3D 'necker cubes' and the famous 'duck versus rabbit' drawings.

The difference between the two translations of the dot column illusion depends on how we interpret the two layers.

If you see them as separate moving sheets, you're focussing on one shade and then the other, picking each out as distinct details of unconnected scenes - a very detail-oriented view.

But when the brain zooms into the bigger picture and recognises the illusion as a single system, one shade (most likely white) is seen as the front of a dot moving across the face of a column before flipping over at the edge and appearing as the other shade (black) on the inner surface.

Some of us fixate more on one than the other. But people whose brains reflect the traits more associated with ASD should be more detail-focussed, a signature of the sensory processing wiring that emerges from autism.

The researchers ran the illusion past 50 adults who didn't have an ASD diagnosis.

Rather than ask the volunteers what they saw, the researchers used a neat feedback trick involving their eyes. If their focus was on the layers as separate details, their pupils would flicker as they adjusted to the two different shades of light.


They then tested the volunteers for autism-associated traits using a self-reported questionnaire.

While the analysis wasn't intended to diagnose the subjects, it did allow them to correlate their findings with measures used to predict ASD.

Sure enough, those individuals who ranked higher on the survey tended to show pupil fluctuations that suggested they were focussing more on the illusion's details than the picture of a rotating column.

It's not unusual to employ illusions in order to check what the brain is up to. The famous hollow mask optical illusion has been explored as a way to test for schizophrenia, for example.

There's more work to be done before such a test will become common place among the other diagnostic practices, especially given the nature of self-reporting on a relatively small sample size.

But given autism often makes it hard for people to communicate – especially among young children – a simple measure of a flickering pupil just might be the thing that helps them get the assistance they need.

This research was published in eLife.


Source: There's a Simple Optical Illusion That Could Help Diagnose Autism
 
Interesting, but as always, I question whether a test like this would be accurate enough to diagnose anything. I saw the image as a rotating column. But my first reaction to some photographs or other types of images is confusion because I'm seeing details that don't add up to anything that makes sense to me. I have to stop and make an effort to see the image as a whole. In other words, how you see it may vary depending on factors which would need to be explored more extensively.
 
I first saw the rotation and when i focused i saw that some part of the illusion didnt match , like the dark dot being in front of the white. I can't realy control what i see it seems; started at it for 3 minutes and what i see changes.

Good luck to understand what it means.

50 people tested realy mean something. xD

Btw was the dress blue and black and gold and yellow? maybe this is the most accurate autism detector also xD.
 
Well, I can't see any rotation or sliding. I assume it must be a gif picture - I have an app that blocks those because gifs drive me nuts - I suppose I could disble it and have a look when I finish work.
 
Meanwhile I'm just here staring at the red dot, what does that say about me? ;)

I have mixed feelings on such tests. Sure, in theory, they could be used as an additional element in favor of a positive diagnosis, but I'm already picturing it as being used, in practice years from now, as a means to rule out the diagnosis in some people. I mean, it's already close to what happens with those of us who manage to make eye contact (or astutely make eye contact with someone's nose or eyebrows & fool everybody in the process).
 
Last edited:
The discovery comes from a team of researchers based at the University of Pisa in Italy

I could see how such people could "lean" towards such a conclusion. :p

But I'm just not buying it. I can't imagine any scientific conclusions made on the basis of only 50 test subjects. Mamma Mia. <facepalm> :rolleyes:

Yeah, I noticed the static red dot in the center as well. But find 50 others here who did the same and I'll still stick to my original statement. ;)
 
what if the autistic person was blind ?!I saw it rotate for a second and then it jumped for a second in the middle then kept on rotating what if somebody was brain-damaged or if they haven't been socialised that presents exactly as autism!
 
Yeah i also did the test linked in the article and the hollow mask illusion doesnt work on me kek am i suffering from schizophrenia :s .

I think many psycho test on the web are realy not trust worthy, i understand why it took me years to actually go and see a therapist, internet is full of crap (maybe this one got something but 50 people isnt enought + many conditions can lead to a same thing.)
 
Rotation for me :)

Technically it shouldn’t even be upright.

A third of the outer sleeve is missing or so uneven at the bottom and there’s a glitch in the flow.
It pauses and jumps for a moment.
Irritating.

Doesn’t matter how many times I search for the sliding sheets the uneveness is distracting and the narrative told me it was a rotating column :)
 
I see a duck flying north but all that says about me is that I am being ornery and me being ornery doesn't help anyone. Please refer to Judge's post of 12:07PM (above in the string). Seriously, I pretty much line up with that. Yes, Yes, I'll go back up and give it a thumbs up. Great post. Keep em' coming.
 
Can see the rotation where it looks like the white dots comprise the outer layer. Can see the black dots rotating as if they were comprised of the outer layer. Can also see the 2d, sliding across each other.

Things like this don't prove what they claim. Especially when you consider how saturated the internet is with claims that perception tests will reveal if your autistic, schizo, depressed, short, fat, skinny.(the latter 4 joking)

If you do develop your perception to see the black spaces and white spaces it can be practically applied when viewing advertisements and other media. Then, you can see... consciously recognize, at least 1 way your mind is infiltrated.

iu


Anyway this cool little gif you posted is pretty much recycled to generate money. Or build an audience. Just like that gold / blue dress thing. Direct traffic, people view ads some click on ads and caching. -or-. Browse the site and hang around. Bump up that SEO ranking.
 
Last edited:
What does it mean if I can consciously switch between 2d and 3d and direction of motion? Bet that would skew their results... he he he.
 
I can see a rotating column. But I am only a detail person in certain ways. I see patterns which maybe implies I'm more likely to see the column? It reminds me of that whale singing tube in space in one of the star trek films. Just saying. ..
 

New Threads

Top Bottom