• Welcome to Autism Forums, a friendly forum to discuss Aspergers Syndrome, Autism, High Functioning Autism and related conditions.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Private Member only forums for more serious discussions that you may wish to not have guests or search engines access to.
    • Your very own blog. Write about anything you like on your own individual blog.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon! Please also check us out @ https://www.twitter.com/aspiescentral

Mom shares the less-than-pretty truth about raising a child with autism in ‘Autism Uncensored’

Status
Not open for further replies.

AGXStarseed

Well-Known Member
(Not written by me)


Whitney Ellenby writes her truth about raising a son with autism in “Autism Uncensored: Pulling Back the Curtain.” ($19.95, Koehler Books) Not everyone is going to like it, and that’s just fine with her. In fact, she’s been reviled for writing what she’s written.

Ellenby was a lawyer in Washington, D.C., working in the Disability Rights Section of the Department of Justice, when she and her husband, Keith, became pregnant with Zack, who is now 17.


Whitney Ellenby, her husband Keith, son Zack and daughter Cassie.


Ellenby doesn’t pull any punches about the first five years of Zack’s life. When he was born, she had trouble connecting with him. He didn’t sleep well. He didn’t respond in ways she thought he should. His expressions were just flat. He never pointed for anything. Yet, how should she know this wasn’t normal? He was a first child.

She doesn’t hide her bitterness when the diagnosis came, and with it, a recommendation for 40 hours a week of therapy. This therapy came with a false hope that maybe he could be trained to alter his behavior so much that he appeared normal.


Whitney Ellenby wrote “Autism Uncensored: Pulling Back the Curtain.”

She dutifully brought her son to Applied Behavior Analysis therapy for months on end. Some behaviors would get better for a time period, or he would move from one behavior to another, but she became aware that it wasn’t working, that he hated the therapy, that it felt like punishment.

She writes that felt like she was losing herself. She looked at her work clothes and realized she was no longer that person who wore those. She felt like she was becoming more and more isolated. She couldn’t take Zack to public places because he would freak out. He started doing things like smearing his poop all over his room at night or eating non-food items. She writes “So this is my life. I am a well-educated woman. I am an accomplished civil rights attorney. I am a woman who spends hours every night on her hands and knees scraping feces off walls.”

The book, she says, was written for parents like her who are struggling and in pain. “When you decide to become a parent, it’s a leap of faith,” she says. You expect a normal baby. You don’t expect a Zack. “It’s not natural to have a total surrender of your identity,” she says. “Are you expected to be happy and thrilled or is there a natural amount of anger and bitterness?”


“Autism Uncensored: Pulling Back the Curtain,” by Whitney Ellenby.

She has experienced backlash after writing the book, she says, mainly from some other parents of children like Zack and from adults with autism who are high-functioning. “It’s just terrible to tell my truth,” she says, of the messages she has received. “I’m offended that your offended,” she says about her critics.

The way she felt, she says, is very normal. “It’s helpful to acknowledge it,” she says.

Ellenby spent five years trying to figure to figure out what went wrong and blaming herself as well as trying to find a way to make him more like a neurotypical kids. She wants parents to “shed the shame. Don’t waste time blaming themselves,” she says. “The numbers are huge and we don’t know why. We don’t know what’s causing it, but it isn’t anything we intentionally did.”

The book takes readers through those dreadfully frustrating years, but there are triumphs for sure. The highs were incredibly high, and the lows were incredibly low.

One of the things Ellenby did that experts discouraged her from doing was exposure therapy to the public spaces that Zack feared.

Ellenby created a routine of bringing Zack to places like the movie theater or a “Sesame Street Live” performance. Zack would have an all out tantrum and often the audience would be hostile to Ellenby until she started explaining to them what was about to happen. She would tell them that her son has autism and that he is afraid, but if they will just listen to him scream for a few minutes, she would talk to him and tell him what was going to happen, and suddenly he would realize that Elmo is on stage and that’s magical or that a movie is going to start and that’s pretty cool.

“Our kids can do so much more than they think they can do,” she says.

Through doing this, Ellenby made sure that Zack was able to go on the high slide at the water park, even though she was too chicken to follow him down, or go to a rock concert.

Her work with Zack also inspired her to create a nonprofit organization in the Washington, D.C., area to offer sensory-friendly events for families of children with autism.

Instead of chasing a cure, she’d like national organizations to build in more services for families, to advocate for more opportunities for people with autism. She’d like autism to be treated like any other disability, with accommodations in public places.

“Our kids are innocent travelers with a disability that makes the world hard to navigate,” she says. “If they are flapping, own it. Don’t feel ashamed of it. Get them out into the real world. Don’t keep them at home because you’re embarrassed. The only way to crystallize skills is to practice them in the real world.”

One of the things she wants to encourage families with a new autism diagnosis to do is to try lots of therapies, but to trust their gut. If something isn’t working or if their child plateaus, try something else.

She wishes she had done more with real world experiences and playdates when Zack was younger rather than him spending his time in 40 hours a week of therapy that didn’t work.

Zack started out in regular classes with some support, but then as the gulf between him and his classmates became wider and wider, it became painful for Ellenby to watch. She had to get over the idea that the experts had given her early on that Zack could “recover” from autism. It was about letting go of the fantasy and pretense. Once she accepted that he’s never going to “recover,” and “it was strangely liberating,” she says. “We acknowledged we had set the bar at an unrealistic place.”

For her, that means she looks to a future of Zack living with assistance and maybe one day having an entry-level job that works for him.

“This is who he is, this is who he’s meant to be,” she says. “Call the thing what it is and ask for what you need.”


Source: Mom shares the less-than-pretty truth about raising a child with autism in ‘Autism Uncensored’ | Raising Austin
 
Wow, this is so intelligently and rationally honest from the parent side. She is a powerfully courageous person facilitating change. I can’t see anything but positivity coming out of her story - after all this is Awareness from the parent side, but also from someone who is working with governmental policy makers to enact change.

What is not to disagree with here? The acknowledgement of her struggles in raising Zack should not have to be hidden. The efforts to challenge him with exposure therapy when the suggested ABA didn’t work brings hope and new understanding and hope that Zack will learn to enjoy life more. She is working to have autism treated like any other disability with accommodations in public spaces. What is not to embrace about this?

I must admit, years ago I have been one of the public who, in the past - with no “awareness” of autistic expressions- observed extreme “melt downs” in public with utter shock, and disproval plastered all over my face (along with everyone else within ear shot) at a struggling parent with a clearly extreme screaming child. This has happened on several occasions, in several places, and yes, you know what my thought were- “Why can’t that parent control their child? Why are they bringing their disruptive child to a store, library, restaurant, or whatever? Why does that parent not immediately leave the place with that disruptive being? Why can’t that child be quieted?”

It’s NORMAL folks, to thinks these thoughts. It’s utterly disruptive to especially someone with intense sensory processing disorder (me) to be so upset by a public meltdown display , that it shatters me physically and emotionally for several hours afterwards. It’s NORMAL for uneducated society to not understand how autistic people FEEL trapped inside your world. So please do not be angry with us...even those of us with aspie but still living as NT.

Parent like the author help create awareness. People WITH autism need to also write their stories and get published too! The anger expressed by some who have lived a childhood like Zack, but can communicate here on these pages- PLEASE try to find a way to publish the “other story” so that society learns from the lived experience aspects. That will be the true “Awareness” we ALL need in order to accept, and bring about healthier change.

The published stories also NEED to be marketed out to the world - because if only read by those living WITH autism, then society will never learn! Understand too, that being angry at scientists, people like me, or parents such as the author, who are trying to understand and gain “awareness,” harms rather then spreads awareness! Hostility turns away people who can enact change and help people with autism. I believe in order to bring true autism awareness, the hostility of “us versus them” (“NT society”) has got to change. If you have autism, and feel anger and hostility, then please put that energy to good pause and write a book, become a social media activist, become a Austism support worker, or autism specialist and spread ACCURATE awareness to society rather then then just spout your feelings on this forum at people like me ( I am trying to help, not harm).
 
Last edited:
I don't find anything wrong with her book. Raising a child with autism is incredibly difficult for some, since there are many challenges and sacrifices that must be made, but it also can be incredibly rewarding. I also agree that finding a cure isn't the answer, but providing appropriate services.
 
I don't find anything wrong with her book. Raising a child with autism is incredibly difficult for some, since there are many challenges and sacrifices that must be made, but it also can be incredibly rewarding. I also agree that finding a cure isn't the answer, but providing appropriate services.

There are 2 negative comments on the Amazon book listing site about the description in the book about dangerous “child abuse” practices. One comment says that the “restrictive holds” the author put upon her son as a child could result in “suffocation.” Note, I have NOT read the book.

I did find one parent’s comments extremely useful though:
She said in the comment response to the above negative comments, “I don't understand, then, why autistic adults don't help families who have children with severe autism? Why aren't they in the home, providing practical, hands-on help? Why aren't they spending one-on-one time with individuals who have severe autism? No autistic adult has ever been interested in spending time with my autistic son.”

I responded then with my thoughts,
“Autistic people NEED to be much more prominent within the autism field as researchers, therapists, and support specialists. There NEEDS to be a change,” and there are autistic disability activists and outspoken individuals who criticise the system, there are virtually no autistic indiviuals at this time bringing about change to the care/coping system for low functioning children.”

So I do ask every one here, why hasn’t it happened?
 
You first.
Excuse me? I already work in mental healt
You first.

Excuse me? I am! I already work in mental health with people with cognitive, and emotional challenges, and continue to educate myself as to autism as lived by those with diagnosis at childhood. I never grew up with any sort of autism diagnosis, nor have melt downs, stimming, flapping or advanced spectrum challenges. I never bit people, or ate non-food items. I have always had complete communication skills from a toddler onward. Even now, I am not diagnosed, and fit in as NT despite ever increasing sensory processing disorders. I clearly have aspie disorders, but just became aware in the past decade.

I am suggesting that the angry autistics who keep criticizing, and who grew up with a autism diagnosis, and possible advanced needs whom clearly have transcended their challenges, and are able to speak out with the clarity I continue to see on social media- as well as Austistics who chose to go into other types of work (accounting, computers, etc)- why not go into careers working with other people who have challenging autism? I continually see people with autism negating the NT world who do the scientific research, the caregiving, the schooling, or the “Lighting up” with “puzzle pieces” as “abusive.” I continually see people with autism being asked to work, volunteer with children who have autism challenges. Where are YOU? I am doing my part.
 
Excuse me? I already work in mental healt


Excuse me? I am! I already work in mental health with people with cognitive, and emotional challenges, and continue to educate myself as to autism as lived by those with diagnosis at childhood. I never grew up with any sort of autism diagnosis, nor have melt downs, stimming, flapping or advanced spectrum challenges. Even now, I am not diagnosed, and fit in as NT despite ever increasing sensory processing disorders.

I am suggesting that the angry one who keep criticizing, and who grew up with a autism diagnosis, and advanced needs whom clearly have transcended their challenges, and are able to speak out with the clarity I continue to see on social media- as well as Austistics who chose to go into other types of work (accounting, computers, etc)- why not go into careers working with other people who have challenging autism? I continually see people with autism negating the NT world who do the scientific research, the caregiving, the schooling, or the “Lighting up” with “puzzle pieces” as “abusive.” I continually see people with autism being asked to work, volunteer with children who have autism challenges. Where are YOU? I am doing my part.

I meant generally. Why do think it doesn't happen?

You answered more specifically.
 
Can't get decent care volunteer numbers for general groups like elderly, let alone more niche groups like autistic folk. :pensive:
 
I meant generally. Why do think it doesn't happen?

You answered more specifically.

Oh, sorry, I thought you were challenging me. Honestly, I don’t know why. Which is why I keep discussing all this on this forum - much to the sheer frustration of some. I read threads where people want to go into coding, or data entry or accounting. That’s a reasonable choice, but I believe that more childhood- diagnosed Autistics need to become Austism researchers, board members, parent helpers, and just be out in the public educating parents, teachers, and the public in general. Otherwise, it’s always going to remain hidden, stereotyped, institutionalized, and controlled by outsiders.

My hypothesis is that the most angry and traumatized by childhood challenging autism are not able to do more then use their voice as activists throughout social media. Perhaps they cannot complete college (online courses), or work? That being said, there could be on-line coaching groups by Autistics FOR parents of “low-functioning” Austistic children. By building on-line support for parents and families, an autistic person with disabilities would be able to coach parents world-wide on what not to to; tell their own childhood stories; and create income (parents would pay for the support coaching). I believe there is such an untapped field and parents are desperate for coping skills.

A brilliant business person (there are plenty of brilliant autistic people in the world) could create a non-profit organization of Autism Support Coaches. I would think that contacting Bill Gates Foundation, Mark Zuckerburg, or Temple Grandin for help in creating or funding such a support system online with regional chapters staffed solely by those with a childhood diagnosis of autism would help everyone.
 
Last edited:
There's nothing wrong with writing one's experiences. How you present it, the context, can be misleading however.

As a guide to parents, this might have been better done as a section or chapter in a book containing a variety of types and scenerios. A lot of people on the spectrum are not like this kid. Nor does it take you further to see whether all the work pays off and positive things occur.

So unfortunately I suspect this will just reinforce the negative sterotyping and scare the hell out of parents and reinforce the 'monster' image in others.
 
Good points, Tom. However, aren’t the most extreme cases of Autism also the most hardest to cope with? I believe that parents who write books are trying to not only help others with the same challenges, but also to document their own journey - therapeutically or otherwise.

I suppose, people do not buy books and read about “normal” autistic people - only the brilliant Bill Gates/Eisenstein types...or about raising the very most challenging children! Many parents read the above books to gain knowledge and support for their own challenges. Many therapists and educators will read it for “better understanding of autism” tomqoute several of the glowing reviews on Amazon.

Until highly autistic people write and publish books that are mass marketed, and create well-known non-profits that are staffed by solely Austin diagnosed people, these books seem to be the only options available.

I agree that media attention to the most extreme autism reinforces the stereotypes and fear. Only when more moderate autism enters the public eye, and educates everyone on an ongoing basis, will things change.
 
Last edited:
I meant generally. Why do think it doesn't happen?

I just read in Psychology Today, that “40% of all diagnosed autistic people have intellectual disability and will require a lifetime of significant care.”

I do not agree with those number because autism is a spectrum, and many are not even diagnosed, such as myself. But, it would explain why there not a lot of diagnosed autistic people available to work as autism advocates, coaches for parents, or on autism non-profits.
 
Good points, Tom. However, aren’t the most extreme cases of Autism also the most hardest to cope with? I believe that parents who write books are trying to not only help others with the same challenges, but also to document their own journey - therapeutically or otherwise.

I suppose, people do not buy books and read about “normal” autistic people - only the brilliant Bill Gates/Eisenstein types...or about raising the very most challenging children! Many parents read the above books to gain knowledge and support for their own challenges. Many therapists and educators will read it for “better understanding of autism” tomqoute several of the glowing reviews on Amazon.

Until highly autistic people write and publish books that are mass marketed, and create well-known non-profits that are staffed by solely Austin diagnosed people, these books seem to be the only options available.

I agree that media attention to the most extreme autism reinforces the stereotypes and fear. Only when more moderate autism enters the public eye, and educates everyone on an ongoing basis, will things change.

You make some great points here, especially -

“I suppose, people do not buy books and read about “normal” autistic people - only the brilliant Bill Gates/Eisenstein types...or about raising the very most challenging children!”

Let me share this morning with you. I was woken just after 6 by screaming. My wife had been woken by the toilet flushing so had gone too, to be greeted by urine soaked pyjama bottoms thrown in the middle of the floor. She went to check my eldest daughter who has ASD but is considered high functioning. My daughter had wet the bed, dumped the wet clothes on the bathroom floor then got back into a wet bed with the same sheets on. She refused to strip the bed or shower, then started screaming at my wife “get out it’s fine.” Bear in mind she is nearly 15. The shouting got louder and more aggressive. I went in but as a person with ASD too the screaming and whole situation was too much for me. Then my younger daughter got up and asked what was going on, and my daughter screamed at her too “it’s none of your business!” As time passed and my daughter still refused to wash or get up my wife got increasingly upset as it meant she was going to be late for work, again. I didn’t know what to do as it would be highly inappropriate for me to drag a half dressed 15-year-old girl out of bed and put her in the shower so I got increasingly upset too.

This is often the type of situation that the parents of a child with Aspergers have to deal with on a daily basis. It’s also extremely stressful and overwhelming for the parent of a child with ASD especially a parent who has ASD too.

As you said, who wants to read about things like this, it’s awful? It also isn’t considered extreme. These type of events may also be the reason why many people with ASD don’t go into the caring profession, because it’s too draining it’s too stressful and too overwhelming to have to deal with on a daily basis. As if our lives aren’t difficult and stressful enough why would you want to deal with this all day every day at work, then go home and have to deal with it all over again.
 
Last edited:
I am so glad you posted your challenging morning, Starfire! I cannot imagine just how stressful all that is. You are right, that is not even the tip of the iceberg (figure of speech) of a day in the life of living with children who have autism.

I mentioned the involvement of Austin challenged people as recovery coaches, and involvement in spreading “awareness” because I have on these forums experienced backlash as to “only NTs” directing the way of research, writing books, and running organizations and institutions for people with autism. Many people with traumatic childhood autism memories are angry, distrusting, and demand that it all change, and so, this is why more people need to get involved....no matter how disabled they are. It’s just to easy to complain online.

Just discovered this blog: Why Can't We All Get Along?
Really enlightened me.
 
Even though I'm on the autism spectrum, I don't really feel the need to be involved in a big social movement or need to "help" those who are incredibly low functioning because frankly I don't have the patience for it or the energy. That doesn't mean I don't want to advocate for continued autism awareness and support services, but I don't see how having a disorder means that I must be involved in certain things. I realize that mentioning the "low functioning" label isn't really politically correct, but it's how I feel.
 
I understand. You would have to have been involved in some of the other contentious threads posted by people with Autism here, who expect society to be full of austistic persons fighting for the cause and denigrating anyone else who wants to help and show awareness, but not in the same way or with the same avenues as they do. So I will say, where are they, and what are they doing to enact the change they want and need? They complain about lack of people WITH autism enacting the changing of stereotypes, and of changing the NT system for finding “cures”, and fighting science that wants to “erase” them, but what are they doing to enact change besides bashing people on forums? I appreciate having these dialogues with you. ❤️
 
They complain about lack or people with autism changing stereotypes, and changing the NT system for finding “cures”, and fighting science that

Sometimes there is a difference in interpretation.

You have said "complain"

I would perhaps said that these issues are "stated"

Often an autistic misunderstanding between the autistic can be between what is meant and what is heard.

So maybe there are many reasons why autistic people aren't more involved.
Being marginalised, socially awkward are two further.

Making a statement that is then received as a complaint (ie heard as such) can be Central to the whole experience.

Where are the NT lining up to hear the autistic perspective?

Will we step forward to be marginalised further by those already involved who are better at putting ideas forward more consistently than we may be?
Or do we survive as best we can.

Too many spoons! Look up spoon theory
 
Last edited:
And I appreciate you talking down to me and just assuming my character without even knowing me or what I have been through. It really makes me want to learn your point of view. Not.

Because I understood a sentence you said and agreed with you, as a disabled person myself...you say and feel something I do not understand! I have not talked “down” to you. I said nothing of your character, or of your abilities. I do not know what you have “been through” but in my world, people who show interest, compassion, and empathy, and who are honest are really trying to understand one another. Sorry if that is not what you understood, as it’s my intention to be honest and compassionate. I DO agree with everything you said in that specific paragraph and that is a positive thing. I can certainly see now that the disconnect in communication style might be something I am not prepared for. I am disabled, and work with people living with mental and intellectual challenges. I have never had this sort of response before!
 
Sometimes there is a difference in interpretation.

Where are the NT lining up to hear the autistic perspective?

Will we step forward to be marginalised further by thosealreay involved who are better at putting ideas forward more consistently than we may be?
Or do we survive as best we can.

NTs seem to be consistently chastised for promoting “destructive science,” for searching “for a cure”, for joining the “wrong organizations,” for spreading the “stereotypes”, for being “bad parents,” for donating money to “bad autism groups,” and for expressing their views that they were human and just did the best they can. They are made to feel that their own post traumatic stress and anguish from raising violent children is somehow unwarranted, and that their being socially ostracized allongwith their children, is meaningless. These people are often denigrated by those living with autism who see everything only from their lived experience viewpoint, and not from the objective view of what the external world also endures from living with autism in the most extreme low spectrum.

BOTH sides want to do good things. BOTH sides want to lesson suffering by ALL involved parties. The NT side has certainly had a long hideous history of mistakes in the mental health system. No doubt about that. But it IS changing for the better. Disability activism and legal rights are slowly changing the world. Some do not acknowledge positive changes at all, and create a battle where it’s “us versus them.” Unfortunately this does not advance the cause as quickly as if everyone could communicate together, and not be made to feel as if they were bad, outsiders, or shamed. Autism is a spectrum that impacts EVERYONE in society that comes in contact with it. So let’s embrace the diversity of society as we need to embrace the diversity of each other in the spectrum- hi or low, or however you care to identify yourself. BOTH sides deserve a voice without fear of reprimand or ostracizing.

I choose to learn ALL sides of this issue.
Why Can't We All Get Along?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

New Threads

Top Bottom