• Welcome to Autism Forums, a friendly forum to discuss Aspergers Syndrome, Autism, High Functioning Autism and related conditions.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Private Member only forums for more serious discussions that you may wish to not have guests or search engines access to.
    • Your very own blog. Write about anything you like on your own individual blog.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon! Please also check us out @ https://www.twitter.com/aspiescentral

Appropriateness

i hear the word inapropriate constantly from support staff and it annoys me, ie- 'em,youve crossed the line- thats inapropriate behavior'.
and i always wonder what line is this,i cant see a line so ive certainly not crossed any, really stupid saying.
 
I wonder if what I'm about to write is appropriate...

The cited article encapsulates neatly everything I don't like about...whatever should I call it..."Aspie Pride"?

The story-pictures included describe things that could have been said by any child. For the few who may not know of it, there has been (and likely will be again) either a segment within a show, or a stand-alone show, called "Kids Say the Darndest Things", or some variation of that. Humans aren't born with the capability to smoothly self-integrate into society. We are, ideally, though admittedly not universally, taught by our parents what to say and not to say, and why that is so.There are missteps along the way, and sometimes those missteps are funny, sometimes they are not.

Notice that those stories don't have a child indulging in racism, bigotry, or sexism? Imagine if we were being asked to excuse a child using the "N"-word; that wouldn't be very cute. And not at all excusable.

Yes, the word "appropriate" is a somewhat fluid, sometimes baffling one. That's not unusual with words and concepts. But at its core, it simply calls for me to attempt to consider how my actions or words will effect other people. That's it. Is that more difficult for some than others? Oh my goodness, yes.

However, I don't treat my diagnosis as a "get out of jail free" card. I would be mortified if I ever thought that any failure of mine in the attempt to get along with others was excused by "oh, he can't help it." I am not deficient. I am not somehow not-as-good-as. I hold myself to the same standards as I apply to others. What I have learned from my diagnosis is to treat my (and other's) failure to live up to certain ideals with even more patience and compassion than ever before.
 
I wonder if what I'm about to write is appropriate...

The cited article encapsulates neatly everything I don't like about...whatever should I call it..."Aspie Pride"?

The story-pictures included describe things that could have been said by any child. For the few who may not know of it, there has been (and likely will be again) either a segment within a show, or a stand-alone show, called "Kids Say the Darndest Things", or some variation of that. Humans aren't born with the capability to smoothly self-integrate into society. We are, ideally, though admittedly not universally, taught by our parents what to say and not to say, and why that is so.There are missteps along the way, and sometimes those missteps are funny, sometimes they are not.

Notice that those stories don't have a child indulging in racism, bigotry, or sexism? Imagine if we were being asked to excuse a child using the "N"-word; that wouldn't be very cute. And not at all excusable.

Yes, the word "appropriate" is a somewhat fluid, sometimes baffling one. That's not unusual with words and concepts. But at its core, it simply calls for me to attempt to consider how my actions or words will effect other people. That's it. Is that more difficult for some than others? Oh my goodness, yes.

However, I don't treat my diagnosis as a "get out of jail free" card. I would be mortified if I ever thought that any failure of mine in the attempt to get along with others was excused by "oh, he can't help it." I am not deficient. I am not somehow not-as-good-as. I hold myself to the same standards as I apply to others. What I have learned from my diagnosis is to treat my (and other's) failure to live up to certain ideals with even more patience and compassion than ever before.

Maybe it would be considered appropriate by NTs? They do sometimes consider themselves the Keepers of Appropriate Behavior.

However, I do consider it rude for you to imply that we are using a "get out of jail free" card (or any other Monopoly plot device) and/or do not understand why not to use slurs (if anyone is wondering, it's because it hurts feelings due to their implications).
 
Great article, and I agree with the author about going on swings as an adult. I will go on a swing quite happily whether I'm just with my husband or if we've taken our niece to the park. I have had weird looks from other adults, but so long as I'm not preventing another child from using the swing I don't see the problem.
 
Maybe it would be considered appropriate by NTs? They do sometimes consider themselves the Keepers of Appropriate Behavior.

However, I do consider it rude for you to imply that we are using a "get out of jail free" card (or any other Monopoly plot device) and/or do not understand why not to use slurs (if anyone is wondering, it's because it hurts feelings due to their implications).

To clarify, I will gently point out that I was deliberately careful in my choosing my words. I don't treat "I" as surreptitiously synonymous with "we" or "you". When I reflect upon and share my experience, I generally keep in mind the saying that "if you've met one autistic person, you've met one autistic person." What works for me, what I am or am not capable of will likely be different from another.

What I found mildly disturbing about the article, and its included examples of ostensibly autistic behaviour, is that all the stories are unfinished; there is no example of any corrective action, nor even the implication that such is possible, let alone desirable.

Had the given stories appeared somewhere else, without any connection to autistic behaviour, I think the common reaction by anyone reading would be: "aren't kids funny? Ah well, they'll learn." As presented in the article, the reaction might be: "aren't autistic kids funny!" I find that problematic.
 

New Threads

Top Bottom