Such a good question, and such a huge problem for me, too. Criticism. Disinterest. The bane of my existence when it comes to sharing art.
@Markness, I think it’s a very interesting question that you raise and I’m gonna posit a guess here that it is very common among any of us who love to make art and dare to share it.
As soon as we share our art with other humans, we are suddenly susceptible to their opinions of our work. I fully believe in the statement “art is in the eye of the beholder.” As soon as you present your art to the world, there is a certain level of control over the interpretation and appreciation of it that will vanish beyond your grasp.
The question is a good one because the risk is very great – when one starts to worry too much about how their work is accepted and the validation they get from that, one can stop creating artwork all together. The saddest outcome.
That’s mostly me just rambling, because I think about this kind of question alot… Here are some possibly more useful thoughts for us to consider.
One. Did you make the art because you enjoyed the process in some way and are you satisfied with your work? If the answer is yes, then you have already benefited from the process, and whether it is received well or poorly won’t really affect the value of making the art.
Two. Do they have a point? If an artist truly wants to improve their work for a wider audience, then it is important to find out what that wider audience thinks. It is difficult to hear criticism. End of story. But, is the artist courageous and confident enough to hear the criticism and actually use it to improve their work in ways that they desire? (And, maybe the answer is no, they don’t have a point and their opinion seems like an outlier. Not every critique is a valuable one.)
Three. Prepare yourself. I think it’s important to share art with the proper intentions. If one is looking for validation, then choose the audience carefully - if one is looking for useful critique, perhaps ask a teacher or an artist community that you respect. Many
many people assume that when you present artwork you’re willingly seeking critique – I think maybe this is where the phrase “everyone’s a critic” could come from. Sometimes, it just sucks when you weren’t really looking for feedback, just wanted to show your art.
I actually have way more thoughts… Like I said I struggle with this question. But, I better cool it for a bit and maybe see what other people think, too.
@Markness, I am right there with you though. I know you may not totally trust me because I didn’t even know what derpy meant initially, but I definitely struggle with this issue that you brought up, so I think about it alot.